Conclusion

Lecture Supplement

Know
              ThyselfOn the Temple of Apollo, at the foot of Mount Parnassus, near Delphi in Greece, there is a single inscription that sums up the Western tradition:

gnothi sauton,

"Know thyself".

(There was also another injunction:meden agan, or "Nothing in excess".)

  • Plato mentions the inscription in the Protagoras. The injunction is attributed to the Seven Sages, who lived in ancient Greece in the 7th and 6th centuries BCE, and are generally regarded as the founders of Greek philosophy.
    • The Seven Sages were Bias, Chilon, Cleobulus, Perlander, Pittacus, Solon, and Thales.
      • Solon (639-559 BCE), "the lawgiver", devised more humane laws to replace those of Draco (which were, naturally, more draconian").
      • Thales (646-536 BCE) was the first Greek to receive the label "wise".
    • The temple was the seat of an oracle, a priestess who spoke for Apollo. She was the most powerful oracle in all of ancient Greece, and was revered as the ultimate source of wisdom. The oracle once declared Socrates to be the wisest of men.

The
              unexamined life is not worth livingSocrates (470-399 BCE) was condemned to death (by drinking hemlock) for corrupting the youth of Athens. According to Plato (Apology), Socrates held that

"The unexamined life is not worth living".

These two aphorisms exemplify the "Golden Age" of Greek philosophy, and the beginnings of the Western tradition.

Cogito
              Ergo Sum, I think therefore I am In the 17th century, the French philosopher Rene Descartes (1596-1650) rejected everything he had been taught by authority in church and school, and resolved to achieve human knowledge by the application of human reason alone. He began by doubting everything except that truth could be known through reason -- everything, including the fact of his own existence. He resolved his stance of radical doubt when he concluded that from his conscious experience of thinking that he must exist:

"I think, therefore I am".

By defining himself as "a thing that thinks", Descartes initiated the modern tradition of philosophy out of which psychology evolved.

Psychology is a full participant in this tradition of Western thought, attempting to answer through the scientific method questions that have been posed by philosophers for more than 2,500 years:

  • What is the nature of knowledge, and how do we come by it?
  • How do our feelings and desires arise?
  • How does the mind work?
  • How do we use our minds to solve new problems and create new things?
  • How do we use our minds to negotiate our relations with other people?
  • How is the mind related to the body?

From Impossible Science to a Science of Mind and
              BehaviorWriting toward the end of the 18th century, Immanuel Kant argued that psychology could never be a science, because science was based on measurement and the mind, being immaterial, could not be measured. Nevertheless, less than half a century later, Ernst Weber and Gustav Fechner asked their subjects to assign numbers to the intensity of their sensory experiences, and discovered the first psychophysical laws. Shortly thereafter, Hermann von Helmholtz began his experiments on the perception of distance and depth, and Franciscus Donders showed how reaction times could measure the speed of mental processes. In 1879, Wilhelm Wundt established the first psychological laboratory at the University of Leipzig, and in 1890 -- only a century after Kant's pronouncement -- William James produced the first comprehensive textbook summarizing the principles of the new "science of mental life".

Wundt believed that scientific psychology was limited to the study of immediate experience, and that the "higher" mental processes, such as memory and thought, were not susceptible to experimental investigation. Nevertheless, in the 1880s Hermann Ebbinghaus measured the strength of a memory by how long it took him to memorize a list of nonsense syllables, doing for memory what the psychophysicists had done for the "lower" mental process of sensation and perception. Francis Galton introduced standardized tests of individual differences in mental functions -- a paradigm quickly adapted, along with Donders' reaction-time method, by Emil Kraepelin for the experimental study of mental illness. At the end of the century, Ivan Pavlov and Edward Thorndike began their studies of learning in animals, and Norman Triplett conducted the first experimental study of social influence.

These gains were consolidated in the early years of the 20th century.

  • Hull adapted Ebbinghaus' method to the study of concept learning, conclusively demonstrating that "higher" mental processes could not be studied quantitatively.
  • Robert S. Woodworth and Robert Bernreuter introduced the questionnaire method for measuring personality and attitudes.
  • Walter B. Cannon explored the relations between emotional states and bodily processes.

By 1931, when Muzafer Sherif experimentally studied the effect of social conformity on the perception of motion, the circle was complete and psychology emerged full-fledged as a quantitative, experimental science of individual mental life in its biological and social context.

What Psychology Tells Us About Ourselves

Psychology has made marked progress since then, expanding its understanding of cognitive, emotional, and motivational processes, their relations with behavior, their biological substrates, and their ties to the social and cultural context in which the individual lives.

In the short lifespan of psychology as a science, we have learned a number of important things about how mental life, and in some cases -- visual perception, memory, and categorization come to mind -- we have a fairly complete understanding of how our minds work. And we have also learned a number of important things about ourselves.

The first and most important theme in psychology is that mind matters. Human behavior is intelligent: it goes beyond reflexes, taxes, instincts, and conditioned responses. We do not simply respond automatically to environmental events. Rather, we behave in accordance with our internal,mental representations of these events. Our actions are based on our perceptions of the present, our memories of the past, and our expectations for the future. For this reason, cognitive functions, having to do with the acquisition and use of knowledge, constitute the primary subject matter for psychology:

  • sensation and perception;
  • learning, attention, and memory;
  • reasoning and problem-solving;
  • judgment and decision-making;
  • language.

Of course, cognition is not all that the mind does, and so psychology is also concerned with non-cognitive functions:

  • emotion, affect, feelings, and moods;
  • motivation, goals, needs, and desires.

As Kant noted, there are three irreducible faculties of mind -- knowledge, feeling, and desire. Psychology must understand all of them.

The second, equally important, theme is interaction -- the mutual influence among causal elements as they combine to produce an outcome. Interactions occur:

  • Between perception, memory, thought, and language: Percepts are shaped by knowledge stored in memory, memories are shaped by beliefs and inferences, and thoughts are constructed and communicated through language.
  • Between cognition, emotion, and motivation: Feelings and desires color our percepts, memories, and thoughts, at the same time as our feelings and thoughts are a product of cognitive activity.
  • Between the person and the situation: The situation shapes the person and his or her behavior, but the person is also a part of the situation to which he or she responds.
  • Between the individual and the group: Group membership influences the individuals who constitute the group, but the individuals also influence the groups of which they are members.

Because of this interactional theme, psychology must be an extremely broad science, connecting many different levels of analysis.

  • Psychology is partly a biological science, because it is concerned with the relations between mind and body (including the endocrine and immune systems as well as the nervous system; and
  • Psychology is also a social science, because the behaviors it seeks to explain are social behaviors, and the environment of the individual is a social environment.

One particularly interesting set of interactions are those between nature and nurture:

  • between our genetic and biochemical endowment and environmental forces; and
  • between our evolutionary heritage and our cultural heritage.

The human mind, with its capacity for intelligence, language, and consciousness,is what the brain does, and the human brain is the most important legacy of biological evolution -- more important than walking upright, more important than having fingers rather than toes.

  • Our large cerebral cortex, with dense neural interconnections, provides an extremely powerful apparatus for general learning, thinking, and problem-solving.
  • Likewise, the specialization of specific cortical structures for language, provides an extremely powerful apparatus for symbolic representation and flexible, creative communication.
  • We have consciousness, which gives us something to talk about, and also enables us to deliberately control our experiences, thoughts, and actions.

The third lesson is that We create the environment through thought and action.

Our capacity for intelligence, consciousness, and especially language sharply divides the dullest human from the smartest chimpanzee, and gives us a uniquely human ability not just to adapt to our environments, but to adapt our environments to us. It is worth noting that the human brain, which the evolutionary psychologists tell us was specifically geared to h. sapiens living naked in the East African savannah of the late Pleistocene era, permitted us to move out of the Environment of Early Adaptation, invent clothes, control fire, and populate the entire surface of the Earth -- including permanent settlements in Antarctica, and maybe someday the Moon and Mars. All without a scintilla of biological difference between our brains and those of Adam and Eve.

There is something of a paradox here, which is that the distinctly human capacity for intelligence, consciousness, and language, which is a product of biological evolution, creates the possibility of culture -- which in turn gives us the means to transcend the very biological forces which allowed it to come about. Unlike other animals, we do not have to rely on learning by trial and error; we can make use of social learning, including sponsored learning, deliberate teaching, in institutions like universities. .Unlike other animals, we do not have to rely on accidents of natural selection, but can literally make ourselves and the world around us.

  • When it gets cold, we can build fires.
  • If the river floods, we can dam it.
  • If somebody breaks a leg, we can fix it.
  • If we don't like where we are, we can change the place -- or move elsewhere.

Such transcendence has its limits, of course: We're all going to die. But within broad limits, it is a fundamental fact of human nature that we deliberately shape the world to fit us. We do not have to rely on accidents of natural selection, or even accidents of learning, to shape us to fit the world.

Culture Defined

Culture may be defined as a set of assumptions concerning ourselves and the universe, and a set of categories for understanding experience, widely shared among a group of people, and transmitted from one generation to the next. It also records the history of the successes and failures of previous generations, on which new generations can reflect and from which they can learn. It includes of a set of institutions, such as churches and schools, that preserve and transmit knowledge and values, and a set of rewards and punishments by which the group imposes itself on the individual.

Some other animal species have something like culture, but none of them have anything like human culture, based on the transmission of knowledge, attitudes, and beliefs through language. Distinctively human cultures are a product of a distinctively human mind (and brain).

Where do we come from? What are we? Where are we
              going?In a very real sense, the human mind is the basis of human freedom because it gives us three unique abilities:

  • To transcend the past, by learning from history.
  • To transform the present, by solving the problems that confront us.
  • And to create the future, by transmitting our knowledge, beliefs, and values to the next generation.

By using our minds, we can change ourselves and the world around us, and promote our advancement into a higher, better, form of life.

But we can do this only if we take Socrates seriously, and attempt to understand ourselves -- not just our place in the universe, but also how our minds work and how we behave. That is the larger task of psychology: to understand the nature of human experience, thought, and action, and the role that the human mind plays in human life.

"Ode 1"

from  Antigone by Sophocles

Translated by Dudley Fitts and Robert Fitzgerald


Numberless are the world's wonders, but none
More wonderful than man; the stormgray sea
Yields to his prows, the huge crests bear him high;
Earth, holy and inexhaustible, is graven
With shining furrows where his plows have gone
Year after year, the timeless labor of stallions.

The lightboned birds and beasts that cling to cover,
The lithe fish lighting their reaches of dim water,
All are taken, tamed in the net of his mind;
The lion on the hill, the wild horse windy-maned,
Resign to him; and his blunt yoke has broken
The sultry shoulders of the mountain bull.


Words also, and thought as rapid as air,
He fashions to his good use; statecraft is his,
And his the skill that deflects the arrows of snow,
the spears of winter rain: from every wind
He has made himself secure--from all but one:
In the late wind of death he cannot stand.


O clear intelligence, force beyond all measure!
O fate of man, working both good and evil!
When the laws are kept, how proudly his city stands!
When the laws are broken, what of his city then?
Never may the anarchic man find rest at my hearth,
Never be it said that my thoughts are his thoughts.


This page last revised 12/20/2016.